When the market is flooded with tons of options with every single brand giving better and better designs with newer features.
Reliability is and will be one of the most important factors every car buyer should consider before buying any vehicle, let alone choosing from some of the most dominant car brands.
BMW, Mercedes, and Audi – these three names will always come to your mind when thinking about buying a luxury car infused with opulent technology, that’s also somewhat reliable and gives that flagship driving experience that you and I deserve.
If you’re also looking to buy from one of the three German brands, this article will make the ultimate brand war and will highlight everything you should know about these three, before stepping into the showroom and buying the car.
History Overview
BMW
The company initially entered the German market in 1916 with the denomination BFW as an aircraft engine manufacturer. But with the change in the post-World War I landscape in general, and the demand for aircraft engines shrinking considerably, things got pretty challenging for the brand.
BMW tried to stay in business by manufacturing motorcycles following up with manufacturing autos in 1928 by acquiring Fahrzeugfabrik Eisenach. During the 1930s, BMW also produced designer automobiles but was forced to switch to the production of military equipment during World War II.
Post-war, after BMW produced kitchen utensils and restarted motorcycle production in 1948, BMW finally stabilized in 1952 with the release of the BMW 501 luxury saloon that laid the foundation of BMW that we know today.
Mercedes
Mercedes’s history started when Karl Benz built the first petrol-powered Motorwagen in 1885 after Siegfried Marcus invented the first combustion engine in the automobile industry in 1864.
Doesn’t Karl Benz’s name sound familiar? Yes, you guessed it right, it’s the same Benz name used in Mercedes Benz but from where Mercedes came into existence. It wouldn’t be wrong to call him the father of today’s luxury automobile industry.
Later in 1902, an Australian entrepreneur Emil Jellinek trademarked the name Mercedes after her daughter. Both these companies came into coalition and became Mercedes-Benz in 1926 which went on to create some of the most iconic vehicles in the 90s and now being among the top brands globally.
Audi
One of the earliest cars introduced by this prolific German automotive engineer was the Type A Sport-Phaeton, which hit the market in 1910 and introduced Audi as a separate carmaker.
It wasn’t until 1932 that Audi was merged with Horch, Wanderer, and DKW under one umbrella, Auto Union AG, a company well recognized for its engineering prowess and quite successful on the race track.
Then in 1985, Audi stepped out of this coalition, changing its name to Audi NSU Auto Union AG at a time when evolution and concentration on modern automotive design and technology were needed to institute a strong brand identity of Audi as it exists today.
This is all about the history of each car brand, and now we discuss each brand’s famous vehicles and the reliability rankings of the brands from some authentic websites like JD. Power and try to find out the winner of BMW vs Audi vs Mercedes.
You May Also Read: BMW vs Lexus
Overall Reliability Rankings
Many people think that German car brands don’t have reliable cars and simply mock German engineering claims, but that’s certainly not true.
Over the years, all three brands have massively improved their reliability game and have produced many amazingly reliable vehicles like the BMW X3, the recent 8 Series Gran Coupe, the Mercedes-Benz CLA, or the Audi A4.
But considering the complex engineering demanding more maintenance, it’d be interesting to see which brand is the most reliable and needs less cost to maintain. With this in mind, BMW seems the most reliable and safer in the long run than both Mercedes and Audi.
When we check studies and surveys from sites like Consumer Reports and J.D Power where we can defer scores of each brand for how safe they are and how rarely they break down. All three brands score great but Audi is slightly behind in terms of how often their cars need repairs. They still make good, solid cars, but Mercedes and BMW cars tend to have fewer problems in the long run.
Just remember – since these are luxury cars, fixing them costs more money. The parts are expensive because they’re high-quality, and you might need to take your car to special mechanics who know how to work on these brands.
Most Common Reliability Problems
While all three brands are going to give you the very best driving experience, the complex engineering makes the cars vulnerable to common issues that most owners face. Audi, BMW, and Mercedes have different kinds of problems but often overlapping ones relating to reliability.
Electrical issues are prevalent across all three brands with window regulators down to malfunctions in the dashboard. Other Exhaust and emission control systems problems are considerably higher than the average in the industry.
Several models from BMW and Mercedes have an exhaust fault rate of about 16-17%, with the industry standard being about 5%.
Costly issues with specific models include Audi’s notorious oil consumption problems in models like the A4, transmission issues in the Q5, and coolant leaks in the A3-specific model.
BMW also struggles with emission control faults in series like the 1 Series and 5 Series Saloon, while Mercedes wrestles with its version of engine mount deterioration and air suspension failures, together with premature catalytic converter troubles. Interestingly, older Mercedes models also have significant rusting problems, particularly in vehicles from the 1990s and early 2000s.
These are the most common issues that I stumbled upon with different articles, especially this Reddit thread with owners highlighting the issues that these German Brands have yet to fix, even in the newer models.
Which Brand Needs Less Maintenance?
For those concerned about the maintenance cost of these brands, let’s have a face-off, BMW vs Audi vs Mercedes, and understand which one is cheaper in terms of maintenance.
According to data from WhoCanFixMyCar, Audi is the cheapest of the three German luxury brands in terms of maintenance costs. The average annual maintenance cost for Audi is $566.10, compared to the BMW maintenance cost of $968 and around $908 for Mercedes.
Mercedes consistently had the highest costs across all maintenance categories. However, it’s important to note that these figures are averages, and actual costs can vary depending on specific models and individual circumstances.
Additionally, other sources like RepairPal indicate that Audi’s overall maintenance costs can be higher than the industry average when considering a longer timeframe and including repair costs.
Winner– Audi
Safety Features and Driving Experience
In the battle of these high-end luxurious German brands, safety is one of the deciding factors that will help us find the most reliable option.
Mercedes – Standard in all Mercedes vehicles include safety features like active brake assist, attention assist feature, blind spot assist, rearview camera, advanced airbag technology, LED headlamps & taillamps, crosswind assist, and LED daytime running lamps.
Audi – Audi has integrated different safety features across its vehicles, such as anti-lock brakes, security systems, overhead bags, Audi pre-sense, adaptive cruise control, active lane assist, and parking lane assist advanced airbag systems, electronic stability control, and various driver-assistance technologies to enhance safety and driving comfort.
BMW being the safest here offers features like an active protection system, active blind spot detection, rear cross-traffic alert, and frontal collision warning with city collision in all its vehicles to ensure the safety of the passengers.
Driving Experience
Better Driving experience comes with technologically advanced integrated systems in the cars. It is crucial to understand the brand to find the most reliable car brand in the market.
Mercedes offers keyless start, sportier styling, panoramic sunroof, and front heated seats, and some AMG Models offer iconic AMG styling and larger alloys which indicate the importance of the best driving experience for the users.
Audi keeps its vehicles updated with the latest technological features, lush interiors, and exotic exterior designs. Its Quattro all-wheel drive, LED lights, Android Auto, MMI Navigation Plus infotainment, and advanced technological features make its driving experience one of the good brands to choose cars.
BMW is long known for its sporty vehicles, speed, upgraded wheels, and suspension. This automobile brand offers powerful and reliable engines, and sporty rides even on the larger wheels, with luxury design. Doesn’t matter which BMW you buy, you’re expected to get the flagship driving experience that is powerful, luxurious, and aggressive.
Lastly, comparing the driving experience of all three German brands, BMW and Mercedes are much better than the Audi. But you’ll find BMW better than Mercedes in many aspects, offering better driving dynamics, integrated technology, comfort, and safety features.
Undisputed Winner – BMW
Best Models of Each Brand
To this date, the luxury car world is still buzzing with innovation and performance from brands such as Audi, BMW, and Mercedes-Benz, among others.
BMW remains strong on the back of its classic powerhouse, giving a diverse line to suit diverse tastes, including sporty sedans and practical SUVs. Mercedes-Benz leads in luxury and tech innovation, while Audi perfectly balances sportiness with refinement.
Below are the best models from each brand serving a different purpose that’ll be enough to narrow down your choices. I have only listed the reliable models so you can always count on buying one of these…
Best For Speed Enthusiasts
- BMW – For Speed Aficionados, the BMW M series is to choose from. The M series is specifically dedicated to those appreciating exhilarating high speed and precise handling, popular models include the new 2025 BMW M5, 2017 BMW i8, 2023 BMW M2, and 2015 BMW M6 Competition.
- Audi – The fastest Audi models include the 2025 Audi RS Q8, 2023 Audi R8 GT, 2023 Audi RS e-tron GT, and 2017 Audi RS3. These cars are here to give you the very best driving experience, come with luxury interior, and behave like a sports car should be.
- Mercedes – Mercedes is not new in creating sports cars, the brand has the longest history out of all three German Brands. The fastest Mercedes models include the 2018 Mercedes AMG C63S, AMG GT 63 S E, SLS AMG Black Series, and 2017 Mercedes AMG GTR.
For Families
- BMW – For families seeking a blend of luxury and practicality, the 2017 BMW X3, 2024 BMW X6, BWW X5, X1, and X4 are perfect given the spacious interior, and large cargo space outfitted with advanced safety features.
- Audi – Audi offers some fantastic options across the board for families giving spacious interior and family-friendly features. These models include the Audi A3 Sportback, Audi Q3, Audi Q7, and Audi A6 Avant.
- Mercedes – The Mercedes-Benz GLB, GLE, and GLS are excellent choices for families that epitomize luxury and space. These SUVs boast exceptional legroom and comfort, equally good driving experience, and safety features.
For EV Buyers
- BMW – For those who are interested in EVs, BMW offers a diverse lineup. Plenty are sporty, efficient, and spacious. Electric BMWs include the BMW i3, BMW iX, BMW i7, and iX3.
- Audi – The Audi e-tron, Audi Q4 e-tron, and Q6 e-tron are excellent choices in the arsenal of electric cars. Whether you’re after a family car or something more luxurious, you can count on these SUVs for a smooth friendly driving experience.
- Mercedes – The brand has some of the best electric cars to choose from, including the Mercedes EQE, EQA, EQS, and EQB. The cars feature some of the best designs, are comfortable, and will give a premium feel.
| Also Read: Best Toyota SUV Models |
Final Words – Audi, BMW or Mercedes?
As far as the stats are concerned, BMW and Mercedes are the dominant competitors in the race for reliability. Audi is a reliable option as far as the maintenance cost is concerned.
Moreover, comparing the reliability score from the JD Power and safety ratings, BMW is more reliable and safer than Mercedes and Audi. Mercedes gets the second place followed by Audi.
In a nutshell, If you are a calm driver, Mercedes would suit you, if you are a sportsman, BMW will amaze you, and if you need low maintenance cost, Audi is best for you.
In this battle of car brands, winners can be different in different periods, and people with change their preferences with each new model launch.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Which brand is better for families?
Mercedes-Benz often edges out the competition for family vehicles due to its spacious interiors and comfort features. However, both Audi and BMW also offer family-friendly options with ample space and safety features.
- Do Mercedes hold value better than BMW and Audi?
Among Audi, BMW, and Mercedes, Mercedes-Benz generally holds the best resale value with a slight edge over Audi, while BMW typically has the lowest resale value among the three German luxury brands; however, specific models within each brand can vary in their resale performance depending on factors like popularity and condition.
- Which brand has better customer service?
Customer service experiences can vary by dealership; however, many users report positive experiences with both BMW and Mercedes-Benz dealerships compared to Audi.
- How do the interiors compare across these brands?
Mercedes-Benz interiors are typically luxurious with high-quality materials; Audi focuses on modern design with user-friendly technology; BMW offers a driver-centric layout that emphasizes sportiness.
- Which brand has more customizable options?
Audi provides extensive customization options through its various trim levels and packages; however, both BMW and Mercedes also offer numerous configurations to suit individual preferences.
- What are the performance differences among the M, AMG, and RS models?
BMW's M models focus on precision handling and performance; Mercedes-AMG cars offer extreme power; Audi's RS models provide a blend of both performance and luxury but are generally positioned below M and AMG in terms of sheer power.
